Dignity at work is emerging as a huge issue
In a brutally-titled article on Stanford University’s Graduate Business School website (“The workplace is killing people, and nobody cares”), professor Jeffrey Pfeffer -- who authored the book Dying for a Paycheck -- calls the modern workplace “shockingly inhumane.” He cites increased stress, lower (or stagnated) pay, and various other factors. Dignity at work in many workplaces does not seem to be part of the equation.
Our relationships to work became more complicated in the past year with COVID, different industries and companies that could/could not return people to physical offices, child care and senior citizen care, lack of human connection, and myriad other issues.
Even before COVID, dignity at work was a concerning topic: only about 46% of employees (less than 1 in 2) trusted or respected their organization to do the right thing. Trust in senior leadership has significantly declined in the past two decades.
Meanwhile, at the manager-employee relationship level, 60% of managers in one global study indicated they “simply didn’t have the time” to respect their employees, as if respect is something that needs to be scheduled in Outlook. (2pm: Respect Dan.)
It’s hard to have dignity at work when managers feel too busy and stressed with deliverables to even respect their direct reports. In late 2016, Google wrote an essay on “bringing civility back to the workplace,” with a good amount of research on micro- and macro-level shots at dignity:
My research highlights how small civil and uncivil behaviors spread, for better and worse. In one experiment, we found that those simply around incivility are more likely to have dysfunctional and aggressive thoughts, although they may be unaware of the connection. Research has shown that people who are typically surrounded by jerks learn intuitively to act selfishly, even when cooperating would pay off. Our environment rubs off on us, and if our environment is toxic, we can expect to stay somewhat sick and to pass it on to others.
Is dignity at work dead? Can it be fixed?
There are significant concerns about workplace bullying and harassment.
Anywhere from 30-90% of US workers are either targets or bystanders. Targets suffer mental, emotional, and physical health harm. There's also a ripple effect on witnesses and families.
Targets of workplace bullying are often women, African-American workers, Latinx workers, workers over 40, and workers with disabilities. When discrimination law moved from a focus on impact to intent in the 1980s, the law became much less effective in dismantling the social hierarchies at work that keep white men in the vast majority of power positions in the US workforce, according to University of Chicago researchers in a 2017 study.
Right now, there are not adequate protections from bias that manifests itself in abuse of power that prevents these subsets of employees from getting ahead.
As such, there’s been a push for a Dignity at Work Act in the United States, which actually could have significant bottom-line impact. Research on workplace bullying and harassment has shown that targets of the bullying tend to be high-performing, highly-ethical employees whose competence poses a threat to their lower-performing, low-in-ethics bosses.
The bully's motivation is to keep the upper hand — an ego-driven control move that's about abuse of power. Bullies are often deceptive managers who trick others into thinking the target is the problem.
Here’s the full Dignity at Work Act, FYI.
There are different models you can follow within your own organization, with the common suggestion being that employees sign a Commitment to Dignity as part of a culture package when they on-board, and are asked to revisit it annually as long as they remain employees. The language can vary based on organization and industry, but it should be designed by a mix of:
Ideally the language would be drafted and then an all-hands meeting would result where the language could be reviewed and a group discussion could occur, as opposed to a dignity document simply being passed down as cultural law of the land (which would be somewhat undignified and thus ironic).
There are several examples online, but University of Cambridge is a good starting point. Their dignity at work policy includes the following language:
A printable PDF version of their dignity policy is here.
There are several examples of this, including one from a badly-performing hospital.
In that hospital, as detailed here, the CEO was determined to take full advantage of the knowledge and commitment of his experienced workforce. A history of labor-management disputes was the core issue, but he managed to put in place a shared leadership model that relied on employees taking personal responsibility for improving the quality of care and reducing operating costs. He created representative councils to give employees meaningful involvement in shaping care practices and the quality of their lives at work.
In the early phases of implementation, the researchers found that employees contributed most to the change initiative when they believed that doing so would increase their control over their work and work environment.
When they followed up three years after implementation, they discovered that the employees contributing most actively to the shared leadership program also expressed high trust in management and perceptions of fair treatment.
These hospital workers managed to turn things around because they were treated with dignity – which employees experience as self-worth, self-respect, and the respect of others. Showing trust, granting autonomy, and recognizing the value of individual contributions all build employees’ sense of ownership of their work and pride in performing it.
The hospital essentially turned itself around because of a renewed focus on dignity at work.
Core principles you want to include:
Again, this is why the process of developing the dignity at work policy needs to include executives, legal, Board, HR, and other stakeholders. The bases must be covered.
When you get to the actual format of the policy, common sections in such a document will include:
People want to know that dignity at work isn’t just a “woke for the sake of woke” policy -- they want to know that it’s fair and it protects everyone equally. That’s why the legal language and context will be important.
If it’s simply another HR document, it runs the risk of being toothless, and then managers have the window to run roughshod over employees and treat them in less-than-dignified ways. You want to make sure the policy has heft.
These are some of the core questions you need to think and work through before you even come to the table to craft a dignity at work policy.
A lot of issues around dignity at work are tied up with some of the major issues of work anyway -- trust, communication, collaboration, effective management, motivation, purpose, vision, mission, and the like.
Typically speaking, if there are good, effective-communicator managers within an org, and they have some understanding of team-building and motivation and priority-setting, there’s a good chance it will be a dignified workplace.
Work is often about money and growth, yes, but the foundation of work is an ecosystem held together by these core human elements. If you can continue to focus on successful development of those elements, you can have a high-performing organization steeped in dignity at work.
Our programs were designed by world-renowned coaches. Sessions only take 5-15 minutes. Get started for free with your personalized program now.
Our expert coaches have designed hyper-effective programs that will help
you improve your company culture and become an amazing place to work.
Coach Marlee (your amazing AI-powered personal coach) will analyse your unique traits and goals to let you know which program to start with (and if there are any you should skip)!
Your recommended programs include:
Inspire yourself and others to see the bigger picture! Increase your comfort and use of abstract strategic thinking to build an amazing culture. Big picture thinking is especially helpful for impactful company communication, identifying priorities and aligning teams with clarity and focus.
Inspire yourself and others to see and achieve grand visions and goals. A focus on goals is especially helpful for bonding and inspiring teams, impactful communication, maintaining focus over time and aligning teams with clarity and purpose.
Strengthen your emotional intelligence (EQ) to bring out the best in yourself and your teams. Awareness of your and others’ emotions and ‘reading people’ is at the heart of bonding and inspiring teams, impactful communication and becoming a great place to work!
During this eight week program Coach Marlee will help you to develop an amazing company culture through experimentation and data and a willingness to empower the opinions, feedback and insights within your team.
In this high impact eight week program Coach Marlee will increase your comfort and confidence to use your influence and leadership to navigate organizational politics and build an amazing culture and place to work!
Develop ‘step back’ mastery for increased self-awareness and mindsets and tools for constant improvement. Reflection and patience is core to consolidating learning, development, strategic thinking and fostering an amazing company culture.
In this high impact nine week program Coach Marlee will help you build the foundations for self leadership and general wellbeing while also helping you to break through self sabotage to develop life long skills for managing personal boundaries and emotional resilience, all crucial skills for leading healthy and happy teams. Enjoy weekly cutting edge science backed wellbeing resources from both Marlee and our wellbeing partner Blisspot.
“Wow this program has totally changed my relationship to goals! Thanks so much Marlee, I miss you already”
"Attention to detail coaching program was profoundly simple but impactful. I am seeing detail more than I have ever before!"
“I think Marlee is impressive!”
“Blew my mind, had no idea how arrogant I have been. Total blind spot. I really like the multiplier stuff”
“As an engineer, I never thought about doing a retro with my family. This has been cool.”
“Coaching with Marlee was simply amazing. 200% recommend!”
“Marlee helped me discover skills in myself and about others on how to work together as a team!”
“I learned how to set, move to take action and progress towards happiness”